Friday, June 22, 2007

पंधरा वर्षांच्या मुलाने केले चक्क सिझेरियन!

पुत्रप्रेमापोटी एका डॉक्‍टर दांपत्याने चक्क आपल्या १५ वर्षांच्या मुलाकडून सिझेरियन शस्त्रक्रिया करवून घेतली. दिलीपन राज, असे त्या मुलाचे नाव आहे. ....
तो दहावीत शिकतो. या दांपत्याची चौकशी करण्याचे आदेश तिरुचीच्या जिल्हाधिकाऱ्यांनी दिले आहेत.

तिरुची जिल्ह्यातील मनपराई शहरात एप्रिल महिन्यात ही घटना घडली. जनरल सर्जन डॉ. के. मुरुगेशन आणि त्यांची प्रसूतितज्ज्ञ पत्नी डॉ. एम. गांधीमती यांनी आपल्या देखरेखीखाली एका वीस वर्षीय महिलेवर दिलीपनकडून शस्त्रक्रिया करवून घेतली. मुरुगेशन यांनी सहा मे रोजी "इंडियन मेडिकल असोसिएशन'च्या मनपराई शाखेच्या बैठकीत स्वतःच ही माहिती दिली, तसेच उत्साहाच्या भरात हा जागतिक विक्रम असल्याचीही बढाई मारली. या प्रसंगाची स्वतःच तयार केलेली ध्वनिचित्रफीतही त्यांनी बैठकीत सादर केली.

"अमेरिकेत दहा वर्षांचा मुलगा मोटार चालवू शकतो, १५ वर्षांचा मुलगा डॉक्‍टर बनू शकतो, मग माझा मुलगा भलेही तो प्रशिक्षित नसेल, शस्त्रक्रिया का करू शकत नाही,' असे समर्थन मुरुगेशन यांनी केले. त्यावर "आयएमए'च्या स्थानिक शाखेने जोरदार आक्षेप घेतला. या डॉक्‍टर दांपत्यावर कारवाईची शिफारस त्यांनी तमिळनाडू प्रदेश शाखेकडे केली. मुरुगेशन यांना व्यवसायातून अपात्र ठरविण्याची शिफारसही करण्यात आली आहे. आता प्रांताधिकारी ही चौकशी करणार असून, आरोग्य खात्याचे सहसंचालक त्यांना चौकशीत मदत करतील.

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

south indian peoples r alway on front for doing stupid things

Anonymous said...

murkhapana ahe !!!! asha bawlat lokana changlich shiksha zali pahije.

माधव बामणे said...

साहस व धाडस हे दोन्ही पाहिजे. साहस तर पाहिजेच पाहिजे. ही शस्त्रक्रिया हे साहस समजावे. कारण ती (शस्त्रक्रिया) प्रवीण डॊक्टरांच्या उपस्थितीत झाली आहे. त्या मुलाचे खरे म्हणजे कौतुक करावयास पाहीजे.

captsubh said...

Although it may be a feat from point of view of 'sahas' & records,it is blatant abuse of the privilege of qualified doctors by allowing same by an unqualified son to operate brazenly.This act is unpardonable coz even if few speciality doctors start allowing their children to perform surgeries on patients,some can even have fatal outcome.All aspiring students have to qualify as doctors before they can venture doing such silly & stupid things!
It has to be nipped in the bud & the guilty doctors stripped of their degrees & privileges to practise.

Anonymous said...

sheer stupidity by fame hungry parents.

माधव बामणे said...

कर्तृत्त्वावर वयाचे बंधन का? पौरुष सिद्ध करण्यास कसली वयाची अट? राम लक्ष्मणाचे वय विश्वामित्र ऋषी राक्षमांचा संहार करण्याकरता घेऊन गेले तेंव्हा किती होते?, कृष्णाने पुतनेला मारले ते कितव्या वर्षी? कालियाच्या मस्तकावर कृष्ण नाचला तेंव्हा त्याचे वय काय होते? (राम, कृष्ण देवाचे अवतार होते असे म्हणून त्यांच्या पौरुषाचा अपमान करु नका). मुलाना बागुलबुवाची भिती दाखवू नका. चंद्रगुप्ताने नंद साम्राज्याचा विनाश केला. तेंव्हा चाणक्याने चंद्रगुप्ताचे वय पाहिले होते काय? ज्ञानेश्वरानी ज्ञानेश्वरी लिहली ती अपु-या वयाने निकृष्ठ ठरली? अकबर कितव्या वर्षी सम्रत झाला? शिवाजी महराजानी स्वराज्याचे तोरण केंव्हा बांधले? माधवराव पेशव्यानी पेशवाईची वस्त्रे कितव्या वर्षी स्वीकारली? अमेरिकेतील १८-१९ व्या शतकातील उद्योगपतीनी कामाला सुरवात कितव्या वर्षी केली.

शिवाजी महरजानी पहिला किल्ला जिंकला तेंव्हा त्यांचे पिताश्री त्यांचे बरोबर नव्हते.

या सर्वावर खटले भरावेत काय? त्याना कोठली शिक्षा द्यावी?

ashay said...

mi madav bamne yancha matashi sahamat aaho.

captsubh said...

Though I find many of Shri.Madhav Bamne's comments on other subjects practical & correct,I do not agree with his reference to mythology or history to justify this operation by a school kid.
We live in an organised civilised world with time tested/proven systems & age limits to have qualified engineers/doctors & other professionals & there is absolutely no scope/room for such silly & stupid experiments.This has to be condemned in strongest words & stopped for good.
Can we entrust lives of air passengers in the hands of a kid son of a senior & experienced pilot to fly & land etc if the pilot father is guiding him?
Come on,call a spade a spade & an arse an arse!

Anonymous said...

Mr. Madhav Bamane, tumhi Ram,Krushna,Shivaji hyanchi udaharna barobar dili ahet pun ithe prashna ahe niragas lokanchya ayushyacha. Ramne kiva Krushnane vait pravruttichi hattya keli hoti. kontahi anubhav nastana operation karne ani nirapradh lokancha jeev dhokyat ghalne hyat kahi shourya nahi.svatache purushartha dakhvaychech aselach tar sanga tya 15 varshnachya mulala Indian Army madhe bharti vhayla ani border var shatrunshi ladha dyayla !!!! Ram,Shivaji ani Krushnane shevti shatrunachach naash kela na ??

माधव बामणे said...

Capt Subhash Bhate and Shri Anonymous, I totally agree with your views. Only trained persons should undertake such surgery. However, I beg to point out that you have forgotten the training part. How would you say the boy was not trained? I am confident the boy received adequate training. No doctor would take this risk just to get his son's name in Ginny's book of records. There is a myth in medical profession that only a person with certain degree can look after health of a person. This example proves that we can train persons for a specific job. Drs. Bang have proved it. They have trained village women as nurses who can perform many things safely. In engineering this is widely used. A person is given specific training for specific task. In medical field it is used as an exception by Drs like Bang. We need doctors for many specific jobs. Vasectomy is the proved method for population control. However due to shortage of doctors we cannot achieve the aim. The example proves that we can have trained personnel for a specific job in the medical field too.

As regard caste system it is prevalent in politics. You can give innumerable examples in the field of politics. A man or woman becomes politician just because his/her parent(s) was (were) politicians. I never meant that just because the father of the boy is a doctor he gets permission to to do surgery. The boy got training and opportunity because his parents are doctors. He proved his skills at lower age and before obtaining formal degree in medicine.

Intention of the boy or his parents never had been to kill some one (at least I assume so). In my example the persons did kill persons, with a aim to rescue the public. 'Rescue' is the key word. In this example the surgery was done to rescue a mother.

I agree we have strict training, we have rules and regulations and we need to follow them strictly, there remains a possibility where these rules don't apply. These are exceptions. Exceptions don't make rule though. However, we cannot overlook possibility exposed in medical field to have persons with specific training for certain urgent necessity. This can be the cheapest and speedy way to achieve the same.

Anonymous said...

Mr. Bamne,

Would you willingly agree to the same trained boy performing surgery on you, should the need ever arise?
Be honest with yourself.

माधव बामणे said...

Anonymous you asked right question and I won't hesitate to say 'YES' After all its skill not the age.

RAMDAS said...

This is very good work and thanks for
Dr.K.Murugeshan and Dr.M.Gandhimati to do this from fifteen years old child. I am very very happy.

माधव बामणे said...

It may be treated as good work provided intention had been not to establish record but to prove that 'skill' is not related to age. This would open a new trend to get medical specialists for a specific job specially in rural area. Path shown by Drs. Bang should be followed.

Anonymous said...

The intenstion is clear here. the parents of the 15 year old boy have said that they wanted their son to make a record which is sheer stupidity.
Finally, its completely unethical. no matter how skilfull you are regardless of ur age, there are things like "ethics" which should be followed by everyone !

Anonymous said...

Mr Bamane, Gammat aahe tumachi. Kadhi vichar kelat ka ki 15 varshachya mulane, kewal vadil doctor aahet ani murkha ani prasiddhilolup aahet ashi eka mahilewar , jichya potat aanakhi 1 jeev aahe ..tichyawar apalyala akkal nasatana shastra chalawawe.. mala tar watate ki hi paristhiti chakravyuha madhe sapadalelya abhimanu sarakhi hoti.. nashibane to chakravyuhat adakala nahi... kahi chukiche ghadale nahi..tase kahi zale asate tar? tar tya dr vadilana tari paristhiti hatalata ali asati ka? ani mi jat mhanun mhanat nahiye, pan mag tumachya mate khatakane pan jyala janaware kapayachi rojachi saway aahe tyane pan surgery karawi ka? aho, pratyax surgeon ne jari wait surgery keli tari tyala Butchery mhanatat
Ani mala watate IMedical council ne attaparyant hya prakarachi dakhal nakki ch gheun tya dr la notice pathawali asel ani mhanun ch tya dr che dusaryach diwashi ase kahi zale nahi ase nivedan ale hote.. teva ugich chuki chya goshtina protsahan dene ani tyasathi chukiche mothya manasanche dakhale dene mhanaje apalyala milanarya lekhan swatantryacha durupayog aahe

माधव बामणे said...

Mr. Anonymous, I feel enough had been said on the subject. I have already expressed that if some 1 can achieve skills more than he/she is expected, we should encourage. Skills are more important than age.

You have raises a question on Pune Roads rightly. I don't know why this has not been put up as and independent topic for discussions on this Blog Spot. I have done some thing already and have given references. Kindly go through those and we should have more meaningful discussion on Pune Roads.

Anonymous said...

Madhav, your comment abut Pune roads is correct. I think there should be a separate topic for Pune roads. We should dicuss in what ways we can improve the condition of Pune roads.People should come forward and pour in their opinions. Dont waste time on how bad the roads are and how careless the government is. We all know about it. So its better we come up with solutions.
I also feel that our opinions hould be reached to the right authorities from Pune Mahanagar Palika.That will be more advantageous then !

Anonymous said...

Mr.Bamane, though your references are correct, one thing we must understand, ,Shivaji Maharaj had a training from his Guru and so did Ram and Laxman. Daring is one thing and knowledge is the other. One would dare to dare to fly an aeroplane but he wont if he doesn't have knowledge. Even you wont sit in an aircraft with soembody flying without knowledge with an enormous daring and with two or three expert pilots sitting by him and guiding him. Will you? Now a days parents are crazy about exposing thier children to alot of things,thatsa good but it should follow the descipline and regulations.

माधव बामणे said...

Mr. Anonymous, Sakaqal Blog Editor asked me to send an email giving my views on Pune roads. I sent it a few min back. It a 4 page letter explaining why roads go bad and also suggetions to avoid mistakes during counstruction and repairs. My document does not blame any one because I know the constriants of the persons responsible for road construction and repairs.

I hope the topic appears here as an independent topic soon.

thunder said...

well...though I am late in entering this debate, I believe that this is nothing else but another attempt where people wants to be famous over night also they do not stop here. Worse is they want that their child also should become the famous no matter come what may.(see any tv program of singing you will come to know) Budhiya is famouse example of it. As long as our channels and newspapers will keep running behind such useless "Sansanis" we will keep listening this more and more. Let us say all the best to us!!!!