Thursday, June 29, 2006

आरक्षण निकष कोणते ?

आर्थीक निकषावर आरक्षण असावे या मुद्द्यावर राज्यात विविध स्तरावर वाद होताना दिसत आहे. राष्ट्रवादी पक्षाच्या शालिनीताई पाटील यांनी, जो जो आर्थीकद्रुष्ट्या मागासलेला आहे त्यास आरक्षणाचा लाभ मिळालाच पाहिजे . अशी ठाम व ताठर भुमिका घेतली आहे. राजकिय पातळीवर आणि पक्षाच्या पातळीवर यामुळे गहजब माजला आहे.

या शालिनीताईंच्या आरक्षणाच्या मुद्याबाबत आपले काही वेगळे मत आहे काय ?
का आपणासही हा विचार योग्य वाटतो ?
जरा व्यक्त व्हाल ! .........

12 comments:

Suresh said...

आरक्षण मागास वगाँस व सवँ क्षेत्रातील गरीब ज्ञनतेला मिळावे.

frozenminds said...

I feel governnment and zilla parishad, grampanchayat schools where majority of the poor in the country educate in these school should be upgraded- good food,clothes, and more important the teachers should be very good so that they can teach the poor children the hygiene good manners ethics and change the syllabus of the school so they become good ,important, responsible citizen of the country and not give them any separate compartment in life the poor of this country are a part and parcel of this country it is our responsiblity to upgrade them and their lives.Not just play politics with them.

माधवराव said...

शालिनीताई पाटीन याना आर्थिक निकषावर आरक्षण असावे हे वाटण्याचे एकमेव कारण म्हणजे, त्याना वाटणारी भिती, मराठा समाज राजकारणातून बाजूला फेकला जाण्याची भिती. त्यांच्या मते राज्य करण्याचा हक्क फक्त मराठा समाजालाच आहे.

घटनेमध्ये आरक्षण कोठल्या उद्देशाने ठेवले हे प्रथम तपासले पाहिजे. तो उद्देश सफळ होत नाही तो पर्यंत दुसऱ्या आरक्षणाचा विचार करून गोंधळ माजवू नये. तो उद्देश सफळ झाल्यावर इतर आरक्षणाचा विचार करावा.

Anonymous said...

स्वातंत्र्य मिळून ६० वर्षे होणार असताना आर्थिक मागासलेपण आणि २मुले १जोडपे हे कुटुंब नियोजन पाळणारे कुठल्याही जाती,धर्माचे असले तरी २५%आरक्षण त्यांना फक्त असावे.बापाच्या जातीवर आधारलेले आरक्षण ताबडतोब बंद करावे.१२०कोटीच्या वाढत्या लोकसंख्येच्या भारत देशात ह्याला पर्याय सर्वनाश हाच होईल.
वि.गो,गोरे.सांताक्लारा

Kiran said...

Well I feel that India needs another fight for freedom. This time not with British Raj but now within itself. What Shalini tai is saying is absolutely right step in the context of current social situation. If some politicians still want to devide society for sake of the votes then even reservation favoured categories should come against it. This is big shame that this government being so good on globalisation is failing in Glocalisation(Local globalisation).

Even Dr. Ambedkar will not fever this. Ultimately society will fail to withstand challenges of modern world. And shame on those people who wants to move this reservation to private level as well.

In that case India will face internal cold war and if greedy politicians wants to make this point in next elections then it will generate new political and social events. India and china are considered as Major power giants in modern world. But if India still going to waste energy on discussing this point then powers like Brazil and Russia will surely over take us in next 5 yrs.
Only visionary politician will set the criteria of economy for reservation rather than caste.

If some thing happens like what I have feared then NRI's like me will be Happy to stay outside in 21st century than staying in 13th Century India. Dont blame us for Brain Drain.

Anonymous said...

Reservations based ONLY on the basis of ECONOMIC BACKWARDNESS, irrespective of caste/religion, and
WITHOUT DILUTING the basic qualifications/age limit etc.is
JUSTIFYABLE/SUSTAINABLE.

Padmanabh Puranik said...

From my point of view the reservation make available is only for economically backward class.
The said reservation is available only for them and for any religion/ or for any cast

shashikant said...

i am a supporter of shalinitai openions. all indians are suffering from the present reservation system this system only benefited the polititions from last 50 years.

Karyakarta said...

We need to understand one basic point: These politicians have nothing to do with caste,creed or any other means of differentiation. All they intend is to keep the public busy,constantly so that they do not interfere or ask questions about the Govt's work, and look they succeed in this!!!! All this reservation nonsense has to stop, If we really want to bring the backward class to the top levels, the first thing is to make education compulsory for all kids, stop child labor,enforce strict attendance, improve school standards,and other things. But none of this is done becasue the Govt is not intrested in bringing the BC classes to the front line,but is more intrested in getting the votes from them. Once they get these votes, they get a chance to make more money in the parliament then then even if nothing works for the BC people, its ok because the money that is earned does the rest of the work for the politicians. All the young generation needs to come together and fight for our own good, unfortunately with our own govt.

Ravi said...

What shalinitai is doing is only to keep her image in politics.She or any of inidan politician is nothing to do anything other than to keep their own interest. I personally feel reservatlion should only be based on financial and educational background of the family concerned. Anyway this is not going to happen in our lifetime.
Ravi

santosh said...

we support of shalinitai patil, beacuse in future need not cast reservation.

Anonymous said...

None of the political party or leader want to solve the public problem they want to work with VOTE BANK policies.The reservation for OBC's is the result of vote bank policy not for solving there problems.The reservation should only based on the economical status. The condition for EBCs should strict & checked clearly.